2023-2024 NFL Season Thread • Page 1285

I'm just glad my coach has @Dinkleberg 's approval

 

Burrow could win 5 Super Bowls and people will be like "but Herbert just needs more weapons, he's really better"

Idc about anyone's lists but it's just so funny that people will say whatever they can to put Herbert higher

 

This is very true. I don't care how much you love a young superstar player and think his gifts are rare... if you know you suck and are tanking for a QB, you take the "multiple firsts" trade every time

 

I like Herbo but him above Burrow is ridiculous

 

I also think its funny that Kirk Cousins, Lamar Jackson, Josh Allen etc get knocked for being stats-lords in the regular season who can't do anything when the games actually matter, but Herbert doesn't

 

I mean, he also has hired a great staff year after year. The defense has been great through multiple coordinators.

 

Doug

 

Do people knock Allen for that? I'm not asking rhetorically, I don't really know as I don't listen much

Lamar absolutely gets knocked for it yeah

 

He seems like a cool guy tbh

 

I remember when Salah’s defenses stunk when he had less talent

 

Someone just did on the last page. I don't see it as often but using this thread as context, if Josh Allen is gonna get that critique then Herbo ABSOLUTELY should

 

I am simply not going to engage in anymore Burrow vs Herbert or whatever discourse

 

I must have not read it, sometimes I gloss over when it's football talk sorry

 

I'm also in a meeting so just kinda skimming

 

Glad my QB is a rookie and I dont have to actively participate in these conversations yet

phew

 

Why can't Stroud win in the college playoffs

Sorry

 

what about Burrow vs Herbo vs Pickett discourse??

 

I"m misrepresenting that a bit actually, he said the Bills themselves were good but flamed out in the playoffs. My bad. That doesn't mean that applies to Allen specifically, it could be that they think the team is failing Allen

 

Can the herbert burrow madness end? They both have good receivers, it’s actually bad that those are the only two star qbs in the last four drafts.

 

That makes more sense

 

So you're saying Lawrence Herbert madness is better than Herbert Burrow madness? Be careful what you wish for lol

 

He's growing on me tbh