Round of 32: (16) Radiohead - Kid A vs. (17) Bon Iver - Bon Iver Bracket

Round one is here. 32 winners of the previous round. What album will come out on top?

NOTICE: PLEASE DO NOT VOTE UNLESS YOU'VE HEARD BOTH ALBUMS. STOP DOING THIS SHIT.

For this matchup, we start with:

(16) Radiohead - Kid A

vs.

(17) Bon Iver - Bon Iver

 

radiohead won't be taking this one from me though. BI, BI is near-perfect.

 

Bibi

 

Apologies to Radiohead, can't vote for you here either. Bon Iver, Bon Iver is a perfect album, and it didn't take out The Joshua Tree to lose in the second round.

 

Radiohead. I’d have voted for 22 a Million though.

 

This is the one that the result is gonna kill me. A top 15 album of all time and Bon Iver.

 

My favorite Radiohead record vs not-my-favorite Bon Iver record. Easy.

 

Im off radiohead. Get em outta here

 

Not even close for me. I re-listened to BI, BI recently and while I respect it it is just not in the same realm as Kid A imo.

 

This sucks

went with Kid A but it was tough

 

KID A

 

Coming to terms with the fact that I will never like Radiohead (a band I generally enjoy!) anywhere near as much as most people like Radiohead.

 

BI BI for me, but I’m fine with Kid A winning. Really tough matchup.

 

me with jimmy eat world but replace “most people” with “people on this site”

 

How can you rank them above Purple Rain then????

 

lol grow up my guy, don’t you have a baby to feed

 

Weird response!

 

Same

 

it's infinitely more weird to get mad and post multiple times about someone else jokingly ranking a list of albums lol. go drink a glass of water and quit being a dork.

 

I’m genuinely shocked lol. You’ve made the most amount of “only on this website!” Demeaning ass posts and then you drop a ranking like that??!?

 

Bon Iver by miles miles miles.

 

wild round

 

Bon Iver is an amazing record, but it's one I have to be in the mood for where as I've listened to Kid A hundreds of times and still spin Radiohead regularly. Truly great matchup here, but it's Kid A.

 

Bon Iver all the way for me. I can respect the importance of Kid A (which I do like) and Radiohead as a whole, but they've never blown my mind the way BI has. Radiohead can't win them all!

 

Easily Bon Iver.