mewithoutYou Band • Page 171

If I had to rank them. But honestly, this band is just so special and incredible and the fan differences on what they prefer is one of the best parts. They had such a varied and interesting career. Also, great collection of b-sides, I think Fairfield is the only one I don't actively enjoy.

Pale Horses
Ten Stories
[Untitled]
Brother, Sister
It's All Crazy
Catch for Us the Foxes
[A --> B] Life

 

Foxes is probably my least favorite of the albums I’ve well versed in (i’ve only listened to AB twice and never heard Crazy), but that’s 10000% a testament to how absolutely insane the rest of their catalogue is.

 

Brother, Sister
Pale Horses
-
It’s All Crazy
Untitled
Ten Stories
-
Foxes

All are an 8/10 and higher for me. Not gonna rate AB Life cuz it’s not my kinda album and i don’t think I’ve ever made it all the way through.

 

I remain the only person I know whose favorite is It’s All Crazy, but it’s a sentimental thing :)

 

It would be my fav if not for PH!

Pale Horses
It’s All Crazy
Brother, Sister
Ten Stories
Untitled
Foxes
Ab Life

 

Foxes
Pale Horses
Brother, Sister
AB Life
Untitled
Ten Stories
It's All Crazy

Thing is, sometimes I LOVE It's All Crazy, but I have to be in the right mood for it.

 

In, like, November and December it’s also my favorite.

 

The hell is wrong with you people

 

Generally my favorite record is whichever one of Foxes, BS, or Pale Horses that I've listened to most recently.

 

this is what makes foxes the clear winner for me.

and then add untitled, and you’ve got my top 4

 

Catch for Us the Foxes is in the conversation for my favorite album of all time. Such a special collection of songs. Pale Horses isn't far behind, but the sentimental factor is too strong for Foxes to fall.

Only album of their I couldn't possibly imagine myself revisiting in its entirety is it's all crazy!, which still has a couple gems (the opener and closer) and a bunch of stuff that's fine. It's just... missing that spark. [A->B] is notably less mature than the rest, but it still works on raw vibes.

 

I got real into AB this year. The pure emotion on it vocally is just too much to deny. I underrated it for years.

 

Foxes brings the riffs

 

phoenix show must have popped off immediately opening with mexican war streets

favorite mwy live moment ever is probably a few years ago in akron where aaron just looked possessed by the energy of the song and just dove into the crowd out of no where

 

I remember the first time I heard Bullet to Binary on mp3.com. as soon as I heard the French part, I was hooked.

 

I don't know if I've ever been able to make it through It's All Crazy in one sitting. Even when I start it with the intent to finally make it through.

 

seeing them play that track for the first time in Pittsburgh (where the Mexican war streets are) is on my list of top 10 all-time concert moments for me

 

Pale Horses
Brother, Sister
[Untitled]
It's All Crazy
Ten Stories
Catch for Us The Foxes
A->B Life

 

Ranking their albums is really hard. It always depends on what mood I'm in or which album I was listening to recently. At this moment it's probably this:

Pale Horses
Brother, Sister
Catch For Us the Foxes
Ten Stories
Untitled
A-B Life
It's All Crazy

 

Also, why rank when you can listen it all and enjoy this beautiful band!

 

Lmao imagine ranking

wouldn’t be me

 

This is probably my ranking too, but I love those top five albums to death - any ranking of them will suffice! A-B is great but Catch is phenomenal. Still can’t get into It’s All Crazy bar a few tracks

 

... They played fig

 

now THIS is a set list. New wine new skins !

 

Huge set list!

Makes me laugh that they emphasised ‘partial’ for Fig With A Bellyache.

Was that dog beneath the waist only partially aroused guys??