The Menzingers - Hello Exile (October 4, 2019) Album • Page 19

Rented World then After The Party for me.

 

Ah yes, love to talk shit about artists’ work by directly quote tweeting them about it. With love though!

(Also what a terrible take, woof)

 

Jimmy Fallon

 

Love it

 

Who doesn’t love a good ranking?

OTIP > ATP > RW = CW for me

They all rule

 

It sure does but I believe we were talking about the preceding track, which references teeth falling out, known as Bad Things, which is categorically their worst song.

 

Also:
OTIP (in serious contention for album of the decade)
ATP
CW
RW
And I'd give Rented World like an 8-8.5.

 

same for me but I'd swap the top two and agree RW still v strong despite being the weakest of those four

 

I still listen to ATP a lot in the car. I adore it. It was my starting point with the band too. I'm very exited for this new album.

Anna is great.

 

OTIP = ATP > RW > CW

 

After the Party is their best record.

 

Also also:
The '59 Sound
Handwritten
Ameri

My wife agrees. I just have too much attached to OTIP. It will always be the one.

Definitive ranking of every song from each just because surely everyone will agree:
1. Gates
2. After the Party
3. Mexican Guitars
4. Midwestern States
5. Lookers
6. Your Wild Years
7. Casey
8. The Obituaries
9. Good Things
10. Black Mass
11. Burn After Writing
12. I Can't Seem to Tell
13. Sculptors and Vandals
14. Bad Catholics
15. Sun Hotel
16. Tellin Lies
17. Nice Things
18. Thick as Thieves
19. Freedom Bridge
20. Living Ain't Easy
21. On the Impossible Past
22. Ava House
23. Boy Blue
24. Charlie's Army
25. The Bars
26. House on Fire

 

Yeah, I get it! On the Impossible Past is great too. That album didn't click with me when it came out, but it's grown on me over the years. After the Party was their first album that I was all-in on right away, so that's the big one for me. But I'll entertain an argument that "Gates" or "Casey" is their best song.

 

After The Party is my fav record 4 shure

 

What is difficult for me is that I believe the 59' Sound, Handwritten, OTIP, and ATP are all probably my top 4 favorite albums of all time. Well, ATP may eventually get there it's only been like 2.5 years.

I just love these two bands so much.

 

Oops! That’s my bad

 

OTIP > ATP = CW > HO, D > ALITAOIT = RW

 

I do agree with Tim that a parallel can be drawn between the two careers, but we differ in our opinions of the albums themselves haha

 

ATP is my favorite as well.

 

OTIP is what got me into the Menzingers so that will always hold a special place in my heart, but ATP is fucking great. These days it's getting harder and harder to find records where you don't have to skip tracks and with those two records I can front-to-back them easily.

 

Also FYI: not sure if all venues are participating but there is a presale in about 15 minutes for the fall tour and the code for my venue is: AMPLIFY

 

Speaking of Handwritten: seven years old this week. Time flies.

 

As a late comer to Menzingers (started listening with After the Party) I feel like they are the rare band that has actually gotten better with each successive album

 

seeing these guys toniiiight as long as this shitty weather doesnt interfere

 

Ohhhh forgot about Shugas! I’ve only been once - I bought integrity blues there. They had a ton, I just don’t live in wicker any more otherwise I would go more for sure