Something Bracket In The Mannequin Wilderness (Andrew McMahon bracket) Bracket • Page 13

Blue
Moon
Break
21

 

Ruthless (wow brutal)

Miss America (tbh Moon is probably my least favorite AM related song. And I'm SO SAD Miss America is going to lose already)

As You Sleep

21 and Invincible

 

Ruthless
Me and the Moon
As You Sleep
Only Ashes

 

She Paints Me Blue
Me and the Moon
As You Sleep
21 and Invincible

Rough matches all around. I love all of these first round picks.

 

Ruthless
Me and the Moon
Break Myself (C'mon, that's a brutal matchup!)
Only Ashes

 

RUTHLESS-5
SHE PAINTS ME BLUE-5

ME AND THE MOON-9
MISS AMERICA-1

AS YOU SLEEP-6
BREAK MYSELF-4

21 AND INVINCIBLE-3
ONLY ASHES-7

 

She Paints Me Blue
Me and the Moon
Break Myself (I really struggled here)
Only Ashes

 

Always considered this to be kind of a Sophmore slump. never clicked for me

RUTHLESS

ME AND THE MOON

AS YOU SLEEP

21 AND INVINCIBLE

 

SHE PAINTS ME BLUE
MISS AMERICA
AS YOU SLEEP
ONLY ASHES

 

Ruthless
Miss America
As You Sleep
21 and Invincible

I'm glad I decided to listen to the album before answering. My instincts were to pick She Paints Me Blue and Me and the Moon because I know them better, but I actually like these two more.

 

SHE PAINTS ME BLUE
ME AND THE MOON
AS YOU SLEEP
ONLY ASHES

 

RUTHLESS-7
SHE PAINTS ME BLUE-8

ME AND THE MOON-12
MISS AMERICA-3

AS YOU SLEEP-10
BREAK MYSELF-5

21 AND INVINCIBLE-5
ONLY ASHES-10

 

Three of us know the truth about the second matchup

 

jk I love you all.

 

Don't take it back, Miss America is one of the best songs on the album!

 

It’s my favorite of his Miss songs.

 

Ruthless
Me and the Moon
As You Sleep
Only Ashes

 

RUTHLESS-8
SHE PAINTS ME BLUE-8

ME AND THE MOON-13
MISS AMERICA-3

AS YOU SLEEP-11
BREAK MYSELF-5

21 AND INVINCIBLE-5
ONLY ASHES-11

 

RUTHLESS
MISS AMERICA
BREAK MYSELF
ONLY ASHES

None of these were easy.

 

Blue
Moon
Sleep
21

 

She Paints Me Blue
Me and the Moon
As You Sleep
Only Ashes

 

She Paints Me Blue
Me and the Moon
As You Sleep
Only Ashes

 

She Paints Me Blue
Me and the Moon
As You Sleep
Only Ashes

 

Ruthless
Miss America
As You Sleep
21 and Invincible

That first matchup is super hard, but "Ruthless" was my favorite when I first discovered this record so I'll go with that haha

 

Gotta step in here to stop the travesty of bad picks. Why is anybody choosing “Only Ashes” for that last matchup?! Maybe the worst song Andrew ever put on a proper album!

She Paints Me Blue
Miss America
As You Sleep
21 and Invincible