Fall Out Boy - MANIA (Jan 19, 2018) Album • Page 143

Folie
MANIA
AB/AP
SR&R
FUTCT
IOH
TTYG

Folie and MANIA are basically tied for first, TTYG is such a distant last that it's not even funny. The rest kind of switch based on the day

 

FAD
FUCT
TTTYG
Infinity
Mania
SRAR







AB/AP

 

IOH
FAD
FUCT
MANIA
SRAR
TTTYG
AB/AP

 

Y'all are fools. For a true fan like myself, this is the only correct answer:

TTTYG = FUCT = IOH = FOD = SRAR = Mania > AB/AP

I can't believe they named an album after that song. Singlehandedly dragging down the rest of the album.

 

AB/AP is really good

 

Yeah, if you skip the title track.

 

AB/AP has a couple duds and a lot of overplayed songs that I am completely burnt out on and never want to hear again. Only FOB album like that for me.


PS Mania is incredible

 

I'll die on the AB/AP being really good hill. Kids Aren't Alright, Jet Pack Blues, Twin Skeletons, Fourth of July, and Novocaine are some of their best songs. Only dud is the title track

 

Title track ain't a dud

 

Title track is a romp, somehow gets better the more people hate on it

 

Ranking this band is hard but I'll try and see what I feel today, but I love this band so much and they're so good that it frequently changes idk

Folie = Mania > FUTCT > SRAR = AB/AP > IOH > TTTYG

TTTYG is the only one I don't absolutely love

 

why listen to tttyg when you could listen to anything else?

 

Nostalgia, fun songs, a cool vocal approach to a tired genre. It's not a bad album just cause the other ones are mostly better

 

Mania is their best album. Everything after that switches, mostly to whatever I listened to last.

Honestly, I had such low expectations for Mania, but it completely blew me away. Find something new with it every time I listen. Hold Me Tight might be my favourite song of theirs.

 

I framed my copy of TTYG last week and noticed you were thanked on the back. Pretty cool.

 

And what is your point? That the trash is actually just as good as the stuff that made them a household name?

 

I mean everyone has to start somewhere.

Didn’t mean anything by it.

 

Gotcha, my orginal post was in response to someone ranking it higher than mania.

 

Most of this album never grabbed me. I told myself I’d be able to enjoy it more when it got warmer, but I rarely ended up reaching for it. Some songs grabbed me, but not all of it

 

Oh yeah that one was tongue and cheek on my part haha. The rest of my rankings are honest though.you can replace evening with pax am and it works for me.

 

folie > cork tree > mania > infinity > srar > ttyg = ab/ap



I love all of them. Ttyg is brought down by lyrics but bolstered by insane nostalgic attachment that will never go away. Ab/ap is just an uneven listen without much cohesion to the record as a whole, but almost every song is good with several reaching great.

 

Ok fine I’ll bite

FAD=IOH>AB/AP>Cork>MANIA>SRAR>TTTYG

 

there’s really no wrong ranking, I’d even accept someone’s fav as TTYG if nostalgia is the driving factor. Sound wise I think it’s the best pop punk album from that era. Extremely solid songwriting but given it’s a debut it’s pretty scrappy and loose but that works in its favor

 

Our rankings are v close!

FAD>IOH>FUCT>MANIA>SRAR>TTTYG>ABAP

 

I honestly think AB/AP is their only bad song. Like, every other song I would've usually skipped has since grown on me. Except that one.