2018-2019 NFL Season Thread Football • Page 1020

And the only other time he won, the ghost of Bob Sanders had to drag him through the playoffs. And that's only after Colts double agent Rechee Caldwell cost the Pats the AFC Championship may he forever rot in hell.

 

Fuck Peyton anyways. That Tennessee stuff was gross. I’ve always thought he was overrated. Yeah, probably top 5 but zero argument for top 2 IMO

 

Peyton haters have to cling to the tiniest of scraps to hate on his talent and productivity as much as Brady haters do.

Get a room, smh

 

Peyton can’t even enjoy papa johns anymore

 

yea, all these arguments are silly lol

 

Yeah, being complete shit in the playoffs is a silly argument huh

 

to be fair, no one can

 

There was never any enjoyment to be found at Papa Johns

 

Tiniest of scraps? 9 One and Dones is pretty brutal as an all-time QB.

 

Brady having a better career is just a fact.
Rodgers being more talented is an opinion sure. But if you think Peyton is unquestionably more talented than Rodgers then you just don't know football haha. Not saying you can't think he's better. But if you think there's NO case for Rodgers being his equal/superior then yeah that's bad.
Brees is breaking his records. That's also just a fact.

 

I don’t hate on Peyton’s accomplishments. I hate on him for making shitty commercials and not being funny but getting praised as if he’s funny because everyone portrays him as this “good ol country boy” even though he got away with some gross shit at Tennessee that people just pretend didn’t happen.

 

On a budget I would love it (before the racism), now I eat digiorno

 

It pains me to agree with @CarpetElf, but Aaron is def more physically talented. Mentally is much closer because Peyton dominated the line. Brady does it too. They can adjust and audible and shift until they get the exact look they want.

 

Tom Brady acknowledges Aaron Rodgers as the GOAT.

Your move, Dave.

 

Rodgers may do it too, I honestly don't study his game enough. Going up against Peyton every fucking year gave me an up close look at him and it was annoying how much he'd audible lol

 

Tom Brady has said that the Buffalo Bills are a great team and an incredible challenge. You can't trust what he says.

Your Move, Matt.

 

Tom Brady has failed to throw a TD pass twice in the last 16 games. Both times were against the Buffalo Bills.

 

you're just saying things, dancing around what i said.

brady has the best career. fact. still doesn't address the QB position as an independent variable.
rodgers is a better athlete. fact. same as above.
brees is putting up better numbers in some columns. fact. same as above.

i'm saying, all things equal, peyton was the best. i don't think anyone moved an offense better than him on the whole.


also, thanks, everyone. this pointless exercise helped kill the last hour at work. haha

 

Boredom brings the worst outta him lol.

 

Peyton couldn't move an offense 5 yards once Ty Law stepped on the field. Better not forget!

 

better career, better athlete, better numbers.....irrelevant

what

 

did you not read the entire post??

 

Let’s not talk about Rodgers plz.

It bums me out his prime is being wasted because of an incompetent HC