Thrice Band • Page 177

illusion just has better production value and tighter performances/songwriting. nothing too drastically different. kind of surprised thats a hot take.

 

ill take this to my grave

 

I agree. Illusion is Identity, but it does it better and sounds waaay better.

 

so 2 giant differences but nothing drastic. lol

 

Vhiessu
Beggars
Alchemy (Fire, Water)
TBEITBN
Major Minor
Alchemy (Air, Earth)
Artist
Illusion
Identity

 

I mean the differences aren't that drastic, just improved

 

I'm not gonna reopen the M/m discussion again, but I think the craziest thing here is actually that you hold Identity and Illusion as equals.

 

Oh and now I'm seeing that this has already rustled other feathers, haha

 

And completely different sounding songs.

 

Holy moly I just realized that you could flip this list on its head and it would very nearly be my list. Hmmm... Just swapping Beggars and Illusion should do the trick, let's see:

M/m > Illusion > Beggars > Vheissu > Artist > TBEITBN > Alchemy > Identity

Yeah....that looks about right. That's frikkin hilarious.

 

Vheissu
Beggars
Alchemy
TBEITBN
Artist
Illusion
M/m
Identity

 

This is definitive.

This is canon.

 

If forced to make a list, I think that would be mine as well.

So, it’s canon for me!

 

Vheissu
TBEITBN
Beggars
M/m
Alchemy
Artist
Illusion
Identity

You could switch Beggars with TBEITBN and M/m with Alchemy anytime though.

 

Beggars
Vheissu
TBEITBN
Alchemy - FW
Alchemy - EA
Artist
M/M
Illusion
Identity

 

TBEITBN is creeping up the list.

 

Outside of Vheissu, that's hilariously close to release order.

 

Man posts list of ‘Star Wars’ films in the order they were released – and the replies are gold

 

To be fair, I could have said:

Vheissu
Beggars
TBEITBN
Alchemy
M/m
Artist
Illusion
Identity

And it still would be true in my mind.

 

My hot take is that they don’t sound that similar but neither is very good

 

hell nah I ain't ranking anything Thrice-related ever again, it hurts too much

 

jacob what was that god damn take

 

beggars > vheissu > alchemy > TBEITBN > illusion > artist > m/m > identity

 

Beggars
Alchemy
Vheissu
Artist
TBEITBN
Illusion
M/M
Identity

 

Illusion is so good, y’all tripping.

You’ve got to, you’ve got to play it againnnnnnn