The Greatest Song of All Time (Low) - The ATL Bracket Bracket • Page 19

Stella is fun, but BYLH is a little better.

 

Some cringey lyrics in BYLH, in my opinion, even though I do enjoy it overall. Stella is way more fun, catchier, and has a lot of really awesome memories tied to it for me from freshman year of college (NP came out the summer between high school and college for me).

 

3a) Weightless
3b) Break Your Little Heart

 

I feel like my taste in music is way off in left field compared to most people on this forum. Across a few different brackets, the song that I want to win almost never actually wins lol

 

Sick Little Games
Break Your Little Heart

Both of these were very tough choices, they actually may be my top 4 songs on the album (actually, I would have to put Weightless at 5 and Damned above it

 

What are your top 10 favorite ATL songs?

 

Kinda bummed that Damned If I Do Ya got knocked out in the first round. It's my second favorite off the album, after Break Your Little Heart.

 

Weightless
Stella

 

I'll give you a list, but in no particular order haha. Some of my faves have done well, so I was probably being a bit dramatic. I haven't listened to three of the albums at all so it won't be comprehensive.

Coffee Shop Soundtrack
Six Feet Under the Stars
Dear Maria, Count Me In
Remembering Sunday
Weightless
Stella
Sick Little Games
Therapy
Poison
Last Young Renegade

HM: Break Out! Break Out!, Lullabies, Poppin' Champagne, Dirty Laundry, Life of the Party

 

Mine:
Six Feet Under the Stars
Weightless
Break Your Little Heart
Damned If I Do Ya (Damned If I Don't)
Do You Want Me (Dead?)
Under a Paper Moon
Backseat Serenade
If These Sheets Were States
Cinderblock Garden
Old Scars / Future Hearts

Honorable mentions:
Holly (Would You Turn Me On?)
A Party Song (The Walk of Shame)
Time-Bomb
True Colors (Cyndi Lauper cover)
Last Young Renegade

 

In no particular order, I think mine would be:

Poppin’ Champagne
Break Your Little Heart
Damned If I Do Ya (Damned If I Don’t)
Guts
Outlines
Missing You
Cinderblock Garden
Tidal Waves
Last Young Renegade
Good Times

Or something like that

 

This is a good list

 

I’m pleasantly surprised haha, I never expect my opinions to be popular

 

Oh and if I’m doing five honorable mentions, I guess I’d go with Stella, Do You Want Me (Dead?), Don’t You Go, Dirty Laundry, and Afterglow

 

And I'm sitting over here thinking everyone else's lists look strange haha

 

My top 10 in no order:

Six Feet Under the Stars
Dear Maria, Count Me In
Poppin' Champagne
Weightless
Backseat Serenade
To Live and Let Go
Outlines
Cinderblock Garden
Missing You
Dirty Laundry

Future Hearts is my favorite album as a whole.

 

Yeah, I really need to listen to those three albums I missed out on. I'll listen through the next three albums as we go through the bracket.

 

End of ROUND 3

Weightless: 12
Sick Little Games: 11
----------
Break Your Little Heart: 13
Stella: 10

FINAL ROUND:
Weightless vs. Break Your Little Heart

If one of the songs reach 13 or more votes before the 24 hour limit, it is the winner.

Go!

 

No order.

Six Feet
Dear Maria
Stay Awake
The Party Scene
Coffeeshop
Painting Flowers
Weightless
A Party Song
Heroes
How The Story Ends (unpopular opinion but this is more of my taste)

Honorable Mention (yeah I couldnt reduce this to 5 so fuck you)

Noel
Vegas
Somethings Gonna Give (Cant believe this considering I was so underwhelmed when it came out)
Walls
Damned If I Do Ya
Nightmares
Afterglow


Yeah this was too fucking hard and made me mad. They have 8 albums and so many different sounds. Also I totally forgot Actors existed and am still incredulous the studio decided they didnt want to record that for Dirty Work.

 

Weightless

 

WEIGHTLESS

 

BYLH

 

Weightless

 

I used to love both of these songs so much when this first came out. Now, I still enjoy both of them, but I think that's probably more nostalgia than anything else. I agree with what someone said above that BYLH has some cringe-y lyrics, so I'll go with:

Weightless

 

Still not as cringe-y as "dirty LAUNDRY" and all those weird sounds on the LYR album, IMO.