Brand New Band • Page 621

At least me personally didn't think you were over aggressive. It's the internet, we are all jerks!

Plus that's the point of this game is to spark discussions isn't it?

 

It is. We're on the YFW semi finals

 

Lol, is that really your favorite on the album? I'd take 70x7, Soco, Jude, Sudden Death and Failure By Design as my top 5.

 

Hot Take:

Mine is Last Chance To Lose Your Keys

 

The No Seatbelt Song is the best song in the album.

 

It really is. That or Shower Scene.

 

It lost to Soco in the first round of this lol

 

The high pitched ringing at the beginning hurts my ears.

 

Sometimes I wish they'd revisit YFW. Like rerecord it and change some lyrics around ala Kaesby Nights.

 

Screw that! I'm outta here! It's back to the album bread and supporter thread for me!

 

Where did I say it was groundbreaking?

The best is debatable.

Where did I say it was a defining song?

The fact that it made it this far shows it's not just some passable song.

Again, I can't change your preference. The problem is that your reasoning has been primarily irrelevant nonsense.

I think one of your only actual points is that Soco has a strong nostalgic pull, but so does Logan, so it doesn't make a strong selling point in either songs favor. The entire album is nostalgia for most of us.

 

Oh come on, stick around. Well start Deja in a day or two and you can support your favorites from that album :)

 

You aren't coming off agressive. I just think your reasoning is weak overall. I can't debate your personal preference though.

 

I love the bread that we make in that thread.

 

This isn't high school

 

Mmmmmmm album bread

 

Maybe the best word is "unconvincing", not "weak".

 

The non lyric based song titles mean I can't remember half of Brand New's songs by name alone so I can't judge these polls one way or the other.

 

I thought we were friends bruh, imma fite u

 

I had to look up WYWTB songs because I used to listen mostly on a burned CD way back when, so I needed a refresher.

 

I forgot it got a bye to the 2nd round, tbh.

If these were just "another pop punk" songs, why did it gain such success? Why was this album so popular? Why is there such disdain for these songs in their context of pop punk? I mean, within Brand New as a whole, yea, all these songs are bottom tier and are nowhere near their best. But this was one of the best pop punk albums of its time.

 

It's some real real good bread!

 

It's banana bread

 

Hot take: Logan and Shower Scene are better than half the songs on Daisy.