Manchester Orchestra - A Black Mile to the Surface (July 28, 2017) Album • Page 90

This feels like a really long ways away but it also sort of feels like the gold just came out and that was apparently June 8th so I'm sure it will go by fast...

 

The River is my favorite of their closers, but Colly Strings is a close second. After that it'd be Leaky Breaks at #3 and Cope at #4

 

Leaky Breaks?

 

Leaky Breaks is their best closer.

 

If Everything To Nothing had been the closer on METN that would take the biscuit

"You mean everything to nobody but me"

 

lol that's what I meant, I do that all the time

 

I'm surprised by how many people like the song Cope, I really dislike the last two songs on that album

 

Those of you that have the album and have listened to the new songs a bit, how would you rank them amongst each other?

 

Lead, SD

The rest

 

The Mansion is my favorite.

 

Cope was a bland closer for me, but I at least enjoy the last half of See It Again.

 

Man, I haven't even listened to either of those songs in a long time, I typically turn off the album after Indentions haha

 

The last half of that song is so good

 

oops forgot shake it out. add that as 11

 

Ok for real this time

Lead, SD
The Wolf
The Mistake
The Silence
The Grocery
The Parts
The Moth
The Gold
The Maze
The Sunshine
The Alien

 

Exciting to see your top half is stuff we haven't heard before

 

Move the grocery to the top and that's how I felt after my listen also maybe move the moth to after lead, sd...

I may have had the maze bigger too... I really can't remember now.

 

This is my ranking after about idk 30 listens my list would've been very different going off two listens

 

You've been playing it hard! A few days ago you were only at a dozen or so haha. Seems like you like it more everyday

 

The amount of people that don't have Sleeper 1972 on their list is baffling to me.

 

When I was first introduced to MO, I was played Wolves At Night, Where Have You Been, and then Sleeper 1972. It was Sleeper that made me realize "holy shit, this band is really good."

But I bumped it off my list when I remembered how much I love I Was A Lid and The Architect haha

 

I've been listening to all their albums a lot lol

So close to being on mine

 

Top 10 songs damn this is hard

Leave it alone
I can feel a hot one
Every stone ( both versions)
I can barely breathe (end of the world)
Where have you been
Play it again sam
Mean everything to nothing
The gold
Shake it out
Colly strings

 

Hot One should be on all lists

 

I think it made mine. If not, it barely missed it