Say Anything - Oliver Appropriate (January 25, 2019) Album • Page 8

I like to imagine Max did like 7 takes and Sherri was like 'eh' the first 6 times then after the last take Max accepted 'pretty good'

 

Favorite off each

Woe
An Insult to the Dead
Eloise
Overbiter
(I honestly don’t remember my fave from Hebrews, I rarely listen to it)
Rum

 

IARB
IDOTG
ST
Hebrews

The rest

This is the correct order. Can't even fathom how shit someone's taste has to be to put anarchy above Hebrews

 

Thank you for bestowing your correct opinion upon us.

Hebrews is one of the worst sounding albums I’ve ever heard.

 

No problem. Have you considered seeing a doctor?

 

can’t imagine thinking Hebrews even approaches being listenable

 

I’d take Hebrews over Anarchy or IDTII any day.

 

Yeah similarly I can't imagine thinking IDTII is better than Hebrews, but here we are ¯\_(ツ)_/¯

 

John McClane through Hebrews is good / exactly what I hope for with Say Anything. A sonic nightmare but lyrically some of Max’s best and most honest stuff. I don’t think I listened to IDTII a single time after the week it came out.

 

opinions

 

Fwiw Hebrews seems like a fan favorite and the opposite for people who don't fuck with the last few records

 

Signal the Rifleman
All Choked Up
Yellow Cat Slash Red Cat or Vector
That Is Why or Spay me
Death for My Birthday
The Stephen Hawking
My Greatest Fear or John Mcclane
#Blessed or Wiremom

 

Love Daze and love Hebrews. Go easy on me pls

 

I must not have a producers ear, as I still love a lot of the songwriting and execution on IDTII and almost none of it from Hebrews

Wonder what Kanye would’ve done with Rum

 

Varicose Visage would have been a good song for Kanye to get his hands on.

 

Let's please not ruin a good thread by talking about Kanye.

 

Just because Max mentioned Kanye inspiring him for IDTII. I'm not really wanting to speak about Kanye further though haha

 

Some of the songs on Hebrews are not that bad but the instrumentals sound wack all over imo. Sounds like he made them on fruity loops.

 

I've never seen so much hate for Hebrews I just remember people being mostly positive.

 

i would never argue with people who hate hebrews bc it sounds like shit, that's pretty apparent and an extremely fair criticism, another obstacle that max placed in the way of accessing one of his records. i really love the first half of hebrews, especially the title track, and "nibble nibble" mostly bc it was the first time in a while that max's songwriting was really reaching me. lost that all over again with i don't think that it is or whatever lol

 

the only reason I place IDTII over Hebrews is because I have to. Truth be told, everything after the first three records is really bad imo

 

Yup x1000

 

Did a deep dive on the SA discography this weekend and it is incredibly apparent that s/t is the only one that hasn’t aged terribly

That being said updated ranking: s/t > Hebrews > IARB > IDOTG > Anarchy >>>>>>> IDTII

 

I really can't imagine not thinking IARB is the best album lol

 

IARB lyrics are sexist beyond belief at points