Motion City Soundtrack Band • Page 44

Not Asking You to Leave is in their top 5 best songs.

Fight me.

 

Fell In Love Without You
It Had To Be You
Even If It Kills Me
Last Night

I mean, it sucked to vote against a lot of those tracks, but it didn't take a lot of thought.

 

Fell In Love Without You
It Had To Be You
Even If It Kills Me
Last Night

 

Fell In Love Without You

It Had To Be You

Even If It Kills Me

Last Night

 

Fell In Love Without You
Antonia
Even If It Kills Me
Last Night

After posting about how It Had to be You was the band that made me love them, it's gotta go up against Antonia, one of my favorite songs ever haha.

 

I won't fight you cus I love literally every MCS song, but this is a hell of a take. Again - not wrong, just very interesting. Never seen someone love that song so much.

 

Fell In Love Without You
Antonia
Even If It Kills Me
Broken Heart

 

Helicopter
Antonia
Real
Heart

 

Fell in Love Without You
It Had to Be You
Even If It Kills Me
Last Night

It Had to Be You against Antonia was the first really difficult choice for me in any of these brackets. Really could have gone either way.

 

Also I thought I loved Broken Heart more than most but I'm shocked it's beating Last Night.

 

Anyone have any idea when Justin is going to release his solo album or Rapture Twins music?

 

Fell In Love Without You
It Had To Be You
Even If It Kills Me
Last Night

 

Fell In Love Without You
It Had To Be You
Even If It Kills Me
Broken Heart

 

Fell In Love
It Had to Be You
Even If It Kills Me
Last Night

 

Fell In Love Without You
It Had To Be You
This Is For Real
Last Night

I’m sure my vote against Even If It Kills Me will be unpopular but I just enjoy This Is For Real more. I acknowledge that Even If It Kills Me is a better song.

 

Hello Helicopter

It Had To Be You

Even If It Kills Me

Last Night

 

Round 2: current totals

Hello Helicopter - 2
Fell In Love Without You - 15

It Had To Be You - 11
Antonia - 6

This Is For Real - 2
Even If It Kills Me - 15

Last Night - 10
Broken Heart - 7

 

Wish I was here earlier for this one. I think some of my favorites on this record seem to be underrated (Calling All Cops, Can't Finish What You Started, Where I Belong, Point of Extinction, etc).

"Fell In Love Without You" was always one of my least favorites, had no idea it was that popular

 

FILW is a great opening jam and this round it’s vs one of my least favorite songs on the album. Makes total sense to me that it is crushing HH.

 

Those are probably my bottom five, ha.

 

Haha I’ve gotten the impression that’s the case for most people. Idk, it might be my favorite MCS album so I’m partial to pretty much every song on this record

 

It's definitely my favourite MCS album and yeah I still enjoy those 5 they're just the least special to me.

 

Ok sorry everyone I really did go MIA for the last couple days. Looks like we have some clear winners. That's the end of Round 2. Final totals:

Hello Helicopter - 2
Fell In Love Without You - 15

It Had To Be You - 11
Antonia - 6

This Is For Real - 2
Even If It Kills Me - 15

Last Night - 10
Broken Heart - 7

I was torn on It Had To Be You vs. Antonia. The rest, you all picked correctly, but the fact that Broken Heart is even close to Last Night.... wait for it.... breaks my heart. Last Night is one of the best 3 songs on the album and best MCS songs in general.

The semi-finals for EIIKM will be:


Fell In Love Without You vs. It Had To Be You

Even If It Kills Me vs. Last Night


Happy voting!

 

Fell in Love Without You
EIIKM

 

It Had To Be You
Even If It Kills Me