Jimmy Eat World Band • Page 35

Dizzy <> 23... depends on the day.

 

no way

 

This is how I feel about 23 and Invented

 

Neither one is way better than the other. They're the two best songs in the discography.

 

Best three songs on each record is impossible, but someone else gave it a go and now I want to:

Static - Claire, Episode IV, Anderson Mesa

Clarity - Lucky Denver Mint, A Sunday, For Me This is Heaven

Bleed - A Praise Chorus, Sweetness, Hear You Me

Futures - Futures, Kill, 23

Chase - Big Casino, Chase this Light, Dizzy

Invented - Higher Devotion, Littlething, Cut

Damage - I Will Steal You Back, Please Say No, Byebyelove

This was like choosing between your favorite children lol.

 

JEW is a top 5 band for me.

Dizzy is a top 5 JEW song for me.

23 is way better than Dizzy.

 

Seventeen, Episode IV, Claire

Just Watch the Fireworks, Crush, A Sunday

If You Don't Don't, My Sundown, A Praise Chorus

Kill, The World You Love, 23

Dizzy, Always Be, Electable

Movielike, Stop, Evidence

How'd You Have Me, Apprecation, Lean

 

Rockstar
Seventeen
Episode IV

Just Watch the Fireworks
For Me This is Heaven
Clarity

Bleed American
A Praise Chorus
Cautioners

Kill
Polaris
23

Let It Happen
Chase This Light
Dizzy

Heart is Hard to Find
Invented
Mixtape

Damage
No Never
You Were Good

 

Can't do Static Prevails

Table for Glasses
A Sunday
Blister

A Praise Chorus
Your House
Cautioners

Kill
Polaris
23

Always Be
Carry You
Here It Goes

Heart Is Hard to Find
Invented
Mixtape

Appreciation
Book of Love
Please Say No

Hardest ones to leave off were The World You Love, Feeling Lucky, and Evidence.

Also, @Craig Manning, did you know your review of Damage is featured prominently in the album page on Wikipedia?

 

Lucky Denver Mint
A Sunday
Ten

Hear You Me
Cautioners
If You Don't, Don't

23
Kill
Polaris

Dizzy
Let It Happen
Always Be

My Best Theory
Heart is Hard to Find
Movielike

No, Never
Appreciation
Please Say No

 

I think I did! There are a few where my review is the first one cited, or one of the first. I think Gaslight Anthem's Get Hurt might be another. I'm glad that Damage review is on there, though, that one definitely means something to me.

 

Hastily picked top threes:

For Me This Is Heaven
Table for Glasses
Just Watch the Fireworks

My Sundown
Hear You Me
If You Don't, Don't

23
Kill
Work

Dizzy
Always Be
Chase This Light

Invented
Coffee and Cigarettes
Heart Is Hard to Find

You Were Good
Damage
Appreciation

 

Oops i didn't rank mine i think i did it wrong guys

 

ok top 3s here we go

Andersen Mesa
Episode IV
World Is Static

Just Watch The Fireworks
For Me This Is Heaven
Ten

Sweetness
My Sundown
If You Dont, Dont

Kill
Polaris
23

Dizzy
Carry You
Let It Happen

Invented
Coffee & Cigarettes
Littlething

Please Say No
Appreciation
You Were Good

 

Claire from Static Prevails is an incredible song and you're lying to yourself if you think otherwise :)

 

Or we have different opinions

 

Claire
Call It in the Air
Episode IV

For Me This Is Heaven
Just Watch the Fireworks
Lucky Denver Mint

Sweetness
Cautioners
My Sundown

23
Polaris
Kill

Dizzy
Let It Happen
Chase This Light

Invented
Mixtape
Evidence

Damage
Appreciation
Please Say No

 

watching live videos of this band is always such a treat. Jim has a lot of Springsteen in him

 

12.23.95
For Me This Is Heaven
Just Watch The Fireworks

If You Don't, Don't
Sweetness
Cautioners

Kill
Polaris
Futures

Dizzy
Big Casino
Carry You

Invented
Heart Is Hard To Find
Movielike

I Will Steal You Back
Appreciation
Damage

 

but Polaris is better than both :)

 

I didn't realize how much I loved Polaris til I registered yesterday... Probably one of my favorites on Futures.

But no, not better than either!

 

why are people typing other songs instead of A Praise Chorus in their BA top 3 this is weird

Episode IV
Claire
Call It In The Air

Goodbye Sky Harbor
Just Watch The Fireworks
For Me This Is Heaven

A Praise Chorus
Your House
Bleed American

Just Tonight...
The World You Love
23

Here It Goes
Let It Happen
Chase This Light

Invented
Evidence
Movielike

Appreciation
Book of Love
How'd You Have Me

 

hmmmmmmm

digits (i'm like the only person who loves this song right? i know it's three songs fused together but they all rule)
call it in the air
robot factory

goodbye sky harbor
clarity
for me this is heaven

cautioners
the authority song
your house

kill
polaris
night drive

let it happen
carry you
firefight

invented
littlething
movielike

no, never
appreciation
lean

 

crimsoooon and cloooover, over and over

i love APC but BA is flawless front to back so its hard to pick

 

23 is better. Just a fact.