Catch For Us The Brackets (mewithoutYou bracket) Bracket • Page 18

I like it too. Haha. I just figured it would only get one vote if that.

 

People really hate that song huh

 

I don’t know if anyone hates it, but it’s easily their most divisive song.

 

I don't hate it. I just don't always enjoy it. I like the rest of the album a lot though.

 

I actually also voted for fig for a hot second before i thought about it some more and edited it

 

Round Two Final Totals:

The King Beetle On A Coconut Estate - 14
Allah, Allah, Allah - 1

Timothy Hay - 12
Goodbye, I! - 3

Every Thought A Thought Of You - 8
The Angel Of Death Came To David's Room - 7

Cattail Down - 14
Fig With A Bellyache - 1

------------------

Round Three:

1) The King Beetle On A Coconut Estate vs. Timothy Hay
2) Every Thought A Thought Of You vs. Cattail Down

 

1) The King Beetle On A Coconut Estate
2) Cattail Down

 

Hay
Cattail

 

The King Beetle On A Coconut Estate
Cattail Down

 

Hmm, tough.

Timothy Hay
Every Thought A Thought Of You

 

Timothy Hay
Cattail Down

It was hard voting against King Beetle but Timothy Hay is such a fun song. I'm bummed Angel of Death didn't make it, I think that was my favorite song on this album.

 

Timothy Down

 

1. The King Beetle On A Coconut Estate - Like others, Timothy Hay is one of my favorite live tracks for reasons everyone has already answered, but Beetle might be my favorite track on this (profoundly underrated) album.

2. Cattail Down - Even though I like Every Thought, I'm surprised it made it this far since it's more of a simple, straight forward song. Although it has one of my favorite mewithoutYou lyrics on it: 'And when they swear their love is real, they mean 'I like the way you make me feel.' Cattail Down is just on another level for me I guess.

 

Also, thank g-d I missed this thread until now because I'd have too much anxiety picking between most songs on their first three albums.

 

Timothy Hay (this matchup is absolutely brutal)
Cattail Down

This has been a satisfying bracket. I think King Beetle, Timothy Hay, and Cattail Down are pretty easily the best songs on the album.

 

Timothy Hay
Every Thought

 

King Beetle
Every Thought

 

Beetle
Every Thought


Always been weird to me that they never seem to play Every Thought live

 

It’s honestly in their top three or four records but that’s neither here nor there

 

The King Beetle On A Coconut Estate
Cattail Down

 

@KidLightning liking this post says all I would’ve said

 

It's definitely underrated. No bad songs, some of their best songs, yet it barely gets mentioned as one of their best.

 

I (respectfully) disagree with this entire post

 

Timothy Hay
Every Thought a Thought of You