2023-2024 NCAA Football Season Thread • Page 212

And Texas was one play away from losing to Kansas State. FSU nearly lost to Boston College. They looked like absolute shit last night against Louisville. It's not hypocrisy at all to say a team that has not been playing like a top four team all year isn't a top four team.

 

No, the tie breaker should involve actual thought.

 

Ok. Hopefully other conferences book better schedules then

 

the results before the injury showed they were a top 4 team, as indicated by the rankings the entire season lmao. they were kept out bc their quarterback got hurt and they didn't want another Cardale scenario.

 

Wow they actually did it

 

It’ll be half big ten and half SEC

 

actual thought shows that 13-0 is a better record than 12-1 so you don't need you don't need a tiebreaker because there literally is no tie to break

 

If Alabama’s best player got hurt yesterday and they still won do you think Bama would’ve been kept out?

 

What do people have against Saban other than him owning your team at some point? Dude is not nearly as controversial as y'all make him out to be.

 

your argument is "haha i was right" and ignoring all the evidence as to why it was a bad decision and making a straw man argument to poke fun at other people on here just because you don't have any other legs to stand on lol. pathetic. you're a 30 year old dude acting like a 12 year old playing call of duty.

 

no because they would have lost to georgia and been very defeated instead of undefeated like the team that deserved to be in lol

 

lol - like I said then let’s just eliminate win loss records and just pick teams off vibes

 

they were left out because the CFP wants an SEC team in the playoff. TV Ratings are more important than rewarding the best teams. Don't pretend like it was anything else.

 

Well I’m saying what if he got injured in the game but Bama still preserved in the win

 

this is ... the argument im making cluck

 

ESPN is actually in charge of college football

 

yeah like why bother keeping track of win/loss records at all? maybe we can add a talent show competition to each game too. that is the best way to figure out which team is actually the most talented i.e the "best" right?

 

UF fan friends celebrating FSU getting left out and even they can admit FSU got screwed lol

 

but the results!!!!!!

 

Ty Simpson beating UGA in the SEC championship would have been the story of the year.

 

sorry I thought you were saying that FSU got left out because of their quarterback. Which I guess does explain why they got left out over UW or Texas. But seems clear to me the CFP would've found a reason to exclude one them in favor of getting an SEC team in the playoff

 

Did they? Their FPI was never higher than 6th and was an average of 9th all year. Strength of schedule is in the high 20s. Game control 15th. Efficiency hovered around 10th all year.

People keep bringing up Cardale Jones as if he didn't beat a top five defense 59-0 lmao. be serious.

 

you're the one picking off vibes...

 

that is the argument the people against FSU would make. because they are no longer one of the "four best" bc the injury. but it's because they were terrified to not include a SEC team lol.