Remove ads, unlock a dark mode theme, and get other perks by upgrading your account. Experience the website the way it's meant to be.

The Wonder Years - The Hum Goes On Forever (Sept 23rd 2022) Album • Page 95

Discussion in 'Music Forum' started by Carrow, Apr 22, 2022.

  1. BenSmith94

    Trusted

  2. twisterman2006

    Trusted Supporter

    Firm believer this version should have been on the album
     
  3. there's a hole in the sky and I'm aiming for iiiiiit

    e: oh, the lick starting at 4:16 reminds me of this

     
    JBoch, Rowan5215 and anotherpancake like this.
  4. tomtom94

    Trusted

    Is there a lyrics sheet for the extended version anywhere?
     
  5. Love this version and glad I don't have get the 7" out to listen.
     
    Carrow likes this.
  6. there's one extra line and that's it
     
    bobsheiskawy and tomtom94 like this.
  7. Rowan5215

    An inconsequential shift as the continents drift.

    classic album forever
     
    Carrow likes this.
  8. JaytotheGee

    Trusted Prestigious

    This version is much better definitely makes me like the song more
     
  9. Pepetito

    Trusted Supporter

    Extended version is better. I agree.
     
  10. Micah511

    We reach for the longest shadow

    Yeah I'm really curious on the thought process here. Why did it need to be trimmed down for the album?
     
    sawhney[rusted]2 likes this.
  11. this would almost certainly have guaranteed a double LP, I'm not sure why they trimmed it for the album tbh
     
  12. MegT585

    Trusted

    This is a long shot but if anyone ends up with any extra tickets for the Albany show in March let me know!
     
  13. tomtom94

    Trusted

    Listening to it in the context of the album, the extended cut is better but I think 7 minutes 20 is a bit long for an album track, and I don't see a way you could make it into, say, 5 minutes and split the difference. In the same way that the 10-minute version of All Too Well is great but I don't think it would work, flow-wise, if you stuck it in the middle of Red.

    To each their own, though.
     
  14. andi182

    Regular

    Yeah, I love this. I think it would have worked great on the album too.
     
  15. Smittzerland

    First time long time (FKA musicfan9795) Prestigious

    Kinda works like the title track of Transatlanticism
     
  16. sawhney[rusted]2

    I'll write you into all of my songs Supporter

    Jesus this should have been the version on the album wow
     
  17. DickyCullz

    I create content for some of your favorite artists

    I’d take this on the album, remove Laura & The Beehive for time and put it before ‘You’re The Reason…’
     
  18. SamLevi11

    Prestigious Prestigious

    I like the album version but yeah this longer version makes it even better. Would happily have them play this live over the other version.
     
    sawhney[rusted]2 likes this.
  19. Steeeve Perry

    Trusted

    Album version was my song of the year, long version is... also outstanding
     
  20. I get it but also like... can't imagine messing with the running order of this album.

    wonder if they'll ever bust this out live?
     
    BenSmith94 likes this.
  21. J12

    Trusted Supporter

    I believe Dan said the only reason it was cut was because it would've forced the vinyl onto two records.

    I'm not sure if that would've delayed the album more, or maybe it was a cost thing. I'm not sure.
     
    Carrow and JoshIsMediocre like this.
  22. twisterman2006

    Trusted Supporter

    Yeah not sure if it was cost or just how the breaks would have been on vinyl, but from his explanation of that was they definitely curate the break(s) on vinyl as well as they can to have the flip of a record make sense as a stop in the album. 100% respect that, but the more I hear this version the more I think adding those few extra minutes would have made a ton of sense in the album without cutting anything.
     
  23. fredwordsmith

    Trusted Supporter

    This absolutely fucks with a capital F
     
    Carrow and sawhney[rusted]2 like this.
  24. Pepetito

    Trusted Supporter

    thats some serious fucking.
     
  25. tomtom94

    Trusted

    Happy Coffee Eyes Day all

    What are you spending $2.77 on to celebrate?