Round of 32: (14) Fleetwood Mac - Rumours vs. (19) Motion City Soundtrack - CTTM Bracket

Round two is here. 32 winners of the previous round. What album will come out on top?

NOTICE: PLEASE DO NOT VOTE UNLESS YOU'VE HEARD BOTH ALBUMS. STOP DOING THIS SHIT.

For this matchup, we start with:

(14) Fleetwood Mac - Rumours

vs.

(19) Motion City Soundtrack - Commit This to Memory

 

a motion city soundtrack album in the top 16 albums of all time. outlasting all but three women ever, all but two rappers ever, almost every non-rock genre. what are we doing here. i don't even like Rumours but im voting it out of principle.

 

Rumours may be the best album left in this IMO. Gets my vote.

 

Eazy Peazy

 

Probably voting Rumours through to the end.

 

Alternatively, CTTM is in my top 3 albums ever and deserves it's spot. I won't be mad when Rumours wins but really no band has ever meant more to me than MCS.

 

Rumours

 

Rumours in a rout

 

I love that Motion City Soundtrack album, even if I think Even If It Kills Me is their true magnus opus. But Rumours is one of the greatest and most seminal albums of all time, and one of my personal favorites to boot. Gotta go with the Mac.

 

Brutal one for me but gotta go rumours.

 

Basically everything Craig said. Rumours through and through

 

Crazy one, but honestly.... CTTM for me

 

This is a hard one for me. Because I know which is the more "important" album but then I know which one I'd rather listen to 100% of the time. Hmm

 

I mean, just vote for the one you like better!

 

I don’t think he’s said it much but I bet if you asked Craig he’d recommend voting for whichever album you like better

 

I thought we were voting on which album had more sales?

 

This should be easy!

 

nah most Spotify monthlies

 

Rumours has the most viral videos of dudes long boarding and drinking juice so I’m voting for it.

Plus it’s the right choice

 

What song on CTTM do we think lends itself best to the "dudes long boarding and drinking juice" subgenre of TikTok videos?

 

You know the answer, Let's Get Fucked Up And Die

 

Oh yeah, that's definitely the one.

 

Rumours

 

This matchup sucks. Hate to vote against Fleetwood Mac like I’m Pat or something

 

I feel like I only remember three songs from commit. I think I loved every song on rumours individually before ever learning they were Fleetwood Mac.