Round of 32: (10) The Beatles - Rubber Soul vs. (42) Neutral Milk Hotel - In the Aeroplane Bracket

Round two is here. 32 winners of the previous round. What album will come out on top?

NOTICE: PLEASE DO NOT VOTE UNLESS YOU'VE HEARD BOTH ALBUMS. STOP DOING THIS SHIT.

For this matchup, we start with:

(10) The Beatles - Rubber Soul

vs.

(42) Neutral Milk Hotel - In the Aeroplane Over the Sea

 

where are all my Urban Outfitters vinyl buyers for me to appeal to for this matchup

 

Probably my favorite Beatles record versus a record I had a tough time getting through a few weeks ago. I understand the mystique of Aeroplane, and there are some great songs on there, but this one deserves to be a blowout.

 

it does indeed

 

Aeroplane absolutely

 

It’s Beatles

 

The Beatles for me, one of my faves by them and Aeroplane doesn't hit me as hard as it used to.

 

Love Aeroplane and still think its lyricism influenced me as a creative person in some way. But it's gotta be Rubber Soul.

 

I cant believe you're forcing me to vote for the Beatles so much @phaynes12

 

i’m literally not. also it’s surprising you don’t like neutral milk hotel since you like little creeps singing weird songs lofi

 

Both are great but if you vote for NMH you are trying way too hard to be interesting.

 

Rubber Soul is my favorite Beatles record. I do love NMH though. Rubber Soul just means way more to me.

Also the group of people joking about the Urban Outfitters crowd (it was a good joke just to be clear) aren’t voting for NMH to seem “interesting.” Come on now

 

I've got to go with Rubber Soul, but it's harder than I anticipated. I really do have love for Aeroplane

 

My favorite Beatles album, so.......

 

lol grow up

 

Yeah God forbid someone doesn't love the Beatles lol

 

The real tragedy is how many Beatles records made the cut vs no Stones records :(

 

again: i tried

 

The Beatles just steamrolled the entire ‘60s.

 

lol lmao

 

Rubber Soul advancing but losing Peppers and Revolver is the bummer of brackets

 

at least we still have abbey road?

 

The Cure losing is the bummer of the bracket

 

But The Stones>The Beatles

jk...unless?