On the Impossible Bracket (The Menzingers Bracket) Bracket • Page 37

Thick as Thieves - 0
Lookers - 16

Midwestern States - 11
Bad Catholics - 5

Charlie’s Army - 1
After the Party - 15

Tellin’ Lies - 10
Your Wild Years - 6

 

Potentially unpopular opinion: Your Wild Years is my 2nd-least favorite song on the album

 

Lookers
Midwestern
After The Party
Tellin Lies (tough matchup here)

 

My whole life is a lie. I thought Your Wild Years was easily considered a top three song on this album by all. Big time reality check for me today! Your Wild Years will always have my heart.

 

I should say that I certainly don't think it's bad by any means (I like every song on the album). Just never really stood out to me and comes at a point in the album where I'm really just waiting for After the Party, tbh.

 

My favorite songs always lose these things and songs I think are alright always win haha

 

A LITTLE IRISH IN YOUR BLOOD

 

Lookers
Midwestern States
After the Party
Your Wild Years

Wild to me that YWY isn't smashing this.

 

Fuck, this is even harder.

Thick As Thieves (I don’t understand how this has had zero votes so far.)
Midwestern States (Extremely tough but this is one of my favorites in their discography.)
Charlie’s Army (I like both of them equally but this one is going to lose so consider this a sympathy vote.)
Your Wild Years (This one was actually easy.)

 

Lookers

Midwestern States

After the Party

Your Wild Years

 

Thick as Thieves - 1
Lookers - 19

Midwestern States - 15
Bad Catholics - 5

Charlie’s Army - 2
After the Party - 18

Tellin’ Lies - 11
Your Wild Years - 9

 

Lookers
Midwestern States
After the Party
Tellin’ Lies

 

Lookers
Midwestern States
After the Party
Tellin’ Lies

 

Lookers
Midwestern States
After the Party
Your Wild Years

 

Thick as Thieves - 1
Lookers - 22

Midwestern States - 18
Bad Catholics - 5

Charlie’s Army - 2
After the Party - 21

Tellin’ Lies - 13
Your Wild Years - 10

 

The last matchup is close, so we’ll see how many votes are in come morning and go from there.

 

This is insane, Your Wild Years is one of their best songs overall!

 

Lookers
Bad Catholics
After the Party
Tellin’ Lies

That last matchup was tough.

 

i cannot believe YWY is not winning in a landslide.

 

Lookers
Catholics
Party
Wild Years

 

yr wild years is other archetypal menz song imo

 

Yeah I don’t understand stanning Casey when YWY or ATP exists

 

Lookers
Midwestern States
After the Party
Tellin’ Lies

 

Thick as Thieves - 1
Lookers - 25

Midwestern States - 19
Bad Catholics - 7

Charlie’s Army - 2
After the Party - 24

Tellin’ Lies - 15
Your Wild Years - 11

 

I didn’t vote for “Lookers” but I’m okay with it winning but the fact that “Your Wild Years” is losing is hurting my soul right now.