On the Impossible Bracket (The Menzingers Bracket) Bracket • Page 35

I missed the last two rounds of RW but I am v happy In Remission won

 

Thick as Thieves

House on Fire

Bad Catholics

Charlie’s Army

Tellin’ Lies

 

Thick as Thieves
Midwestern States
Bad Catholics
Charlie’s Army
Tellin’ Lies

 

Black Mass - 8
Thick as Thieves - 12

House on Fire - 7
Midwestern States - 13

Bad Catholics - 11
Livin’ Ain’t Easy - 9

Charlie’s Army - 10
The Bars - 10

Tellin’ Lies - 18
Boy Blue - 2

 

Thick as Thieves
Midwestern States
Livin’ Ain’t Easy
Charlie’s Army
Tellin’ Lies

 

Thick
Midwestern
Bad
Charlie’s
Tellin

 

Still very much love this album:
Black Mass (top 3 song on the album for me, although I do love Thieves as well)
Midwestern States
Bad Catholics (both mid-tier songs on the album for me)
Charlie's Army (love this song and The Bars is probably my least favorite song on the album, so easy choice for me)
Tellin' Lies

 

Black Mass - 9
Thick as Thieves - 14

House on Fire - 7
Midwestern States - 16

Bad Catholics - 13
Livin’ Ain’t Easy - 10

Charlie’s Army - 13
The Bars - 10

Tellin’ Lies - 21
Boy Blue - 2

 

Thick as Thieves
Midwestern States
Bad Catholics
Charlie’s Army
Tellin’ Lies

 

Starting to see some separation in these matchups.

 

Charlies army might be my least favorite song on the album

 

It’s not my favorite, but I really like it. I don’t think there’s a bad song on this record.

 

Thick as Thieves
Midwestern States
Bad Catholics
Charlie’s Army
Tellin’ Lies

This was a pretty easy round for me.

 

Black Mass - 9
Thick as Thieves - 16

House on Fire - 7
Midwestern States - 18

Bad Catholics - 15
Livin’ Ain’t Easy - 10

Charlie’s Army - 15
The Bars - 10

Tellin’ Lies - 23
Boy Blue - 2

 

Charlie’s Army is the most fun Menzingers song, makes me smile every time

 

The Bars doesn’t deserve this!

 

Leaving this round open until noon EST tomorrow.

 

Funnily enough, The Bars and Boy Blue are my least favourite haha.

 

Thick as Thieves
Midwestern States
Bad Catholics
Charlie’s Army
Tellin’ Lies

 

Black Mass - 9
Thick as Thieves - 17

House on Fire - 7
Midwestern States - 19

Bad Catholics - 16
Livin’ Ain’t Easy - 10

Charlie’s Army - 16
The Bars - 10

Tellin’ Lies - 24
Boy Blue - 2

 

Oh fuck. This one is going to be extremely difficult.

Thick As Thieves
Midwestern States
Bad Catholics
Charlie’s Army
Boy Blue

Yep. Incredibly difficult.

 

There isn’t. Even the “worst” songs are standouts.

 

The gaps are likely too large for anything to change, but as promised, 2 hours left on this round.

 

Thick as Thieves
House on Fire
Bad Catholics
Charlie’s Army
Tellin’ Lies

 

Thick as Thieves
House on Fire
Livin Ain’t Easy
Charlie’s Army
Tellin Lies