[Revisited]Weekly Poll: Favorite mewithoutYou Album • Page 4

the most I can say is that its definitely better than AB

 

I’m conflicted cause I feel like Untitled is a perfect album but I also don’t enjoy listening to it as much as something like Pale Horses

 

untitled is their best album

 

I love most of it but it's still my least favourite of their great albums.

 

Brother, Sister
Catch For Us the Foxes
Untitled
Pale Horses
It's all crazy
Ten Stories
AB

 

Tier 1:

Brother, Sister
[Untitled]

Tier 1 1/2:

Pale Horses
Catch For Us the Foxes

Tier 2:

[untitled] EP
Ten Stories
it’s all crazy! it’s all false! it’s all a dream! it’s alright.
[A—>B] Life

There is no tier 3 mwY record.

 

what is this tier nonsense

 

Untitled feels like the B,S to Pale Horses CFUTF. They both take an established sound and just push it out in different directions.

CFUTF will probably always be my favorite and the one I consider their best but a discography this stellar makes it hard to rank. I’ll try though

CFUTF
Untitled
B,S
PH
TS
Crazy
AB

 

its like a cake

 

Don’t turn my tiers into tears

 

Catch all day every day, baby!

 

I voted Catch but the ep is amazing

I like it better than the album - they completely killed it

 

Catch>

 

the ep IS better than the album

except for solstice and tortoises

 

The EP mostly bores me tbh, probably my least favourite thing they've released.

 

1. Catch for Us the Foxes
2. Pale Horses
3. [untitled]
4. the rest
5. [placeholder for emphasis]
6. it's all crazy!

I do REALLY love [untitled]. It's such an excellent work of art that thematically connected w/ me a lot this past year. But, Foxes has too much sentimental value to ever be usurped, & I enjoy listening to Pale Horses a little more.

 

smh, the disrespect

 

you’re everyone else
you’re everyone else
you’re everyone else
you’re everyone else
you’re everyone else
you’re everyone else
you’re everyone else
you’re everyone else

 

Just kidding, I just adore “it’s all crazy...”

 

It’s a great but odd album for me. The songwriting on it is insane but it just doesn’t have all the dynamics of a terrific mwY record for me.

 

amazing record - my third favorite

love the Neutral Milk Hotel vibe

 

I wish it was as good as Neutral Milk Hotel. I actually love the sound they went for on that album I just don't like the songs much. Still some greats on there.

 

Went to Pittsburgh today to hit up a dope comic shop, & on my way home, passed a sign for West End Bridge. Reminded me of the flawless "Mexican War Streets," which is behind only "Fox's Dream" these days in my mwY songs ranking.

Man, Pale Horses is SO good.

 

Pale Horses is crazy good. “Magic Lantern Days” could be my favorite song of theirs in general.