Taking Back Sunday Band • Page 245

Remaster it or rerecord it. Well, there is the acoustic album, but I haven't listened to it so maybe it is better.

 

@BTDandFeelingThis told me your top 3 was HI, TW and NA.

 

NA is forth. It's TW, WYWTB, HI and then New Again. Still, great list!

 

Ok I gotta do it:

NA
Happiness Is
Tidal Wave
WYWTB
Louder Now
TAYF
TBS

 

WYWTB
TW
HI
LN
NA
S/T
TAYF

 

Oh, we ranking?

WYWTB
HI
WYWTB
TAYF
LN
WYWTB
TW
WYWTB
NA
S/T

Yea, I've been drinking.

 

I like your list but I think you forgot to include WYWTB

 

The release that Silverstein just put out, I'd love something similar from them. Hearing studio versions of Fred and Matt's songs with John's vocals would be interesting.

 

That would suck. John has the worst voice between the 3.

 

Excuse you? Don’t you dare diss Nolan

 

I went to both shows at the Palladium last night. First night they played Where You Want To Be...I think that's my favorite album. They didn't sound that good though, second night they sounded way better, better crowd too. Lastly, I still love Tell All Your Friends.

 

I hate to say it, but it's true haha. Also the worst guitarist out of the three. I'll never forget seeing them at a reunion show and John fake playing lead parts.

I stood right in front of him and he literally turned the volume down on his guitar to play the bridge/solo to Error Operator while Nathan was in the background slaying away on it haha. I'm he's figured it out by now, but that is something I will NEVER forget.

Actually, I noticed Nathan has a GREAT voice. He just has a much stronger voice. He sang a lot of back up at the show I was at last week.

 

I love John. But he just doesn’t compare to Fred and especially Fazzi (who probably has more talent than the entire band)

 

Ftfy

 

This hurt my feelings.

 

I like John’s voice the most when he gets loud/screams a bit. His quiet talky-sing voice isn’t as good these days

 

John probably does technically have the worst voice but it's the most interesting of the 3 to me anyways

 

Dude. Fazzi was awesome when I saw him playing guitar for the movielife a couple years ago.

 

John's screams are so fucking good

 

Now that Eddie’s out of the band, he does play the Error Operator solo. Before Eddie left though, I think he and Nathan doubled-up on it. Speaking of Nathan, I agree with what you said about his voice plus the dude’s a great guitar player to boot. I saw a recent video of them playing “Miami” and he slays that solo.
There’s a video from Warped Tour 2012 where Nathan filled in for John when John’s first kid was born and he crushed all the vocal parts.

 

Oh yeah! I remember watching those warped tour videos. He killed it!

 

Wow, yeah I never thought of it but even though John is amazing, I'd still probably say he's below the other two vocal wise.

 

I can hardly hear John sing at live shows...I can hardly hear anyone sing unless they double up....

 

John is my favorite of the bunch, don't really care who is 'better'.

 

He starts the song off by saying "A band profited greatly by stealing the words from this song, maybe you can put the pieces together."

Anyone know what band he's talking about ??