Bracket Thread for a Band Called The Maine Bracket • Page 33

Black butt baby


This has showed me that The Maine have SOOOOO many great songs. I don't think either of these are "their best", but i also can't decide which should be. Maybe it'll be more clear with the next record

 

Black Butterflies

"Identify" is not even a top 30 Maine song, how is this the final?

 

Identify

By far this has been the hardest choice for me the whole bracket.

 

i think black butterflies is a better song but i enjoy identify more, so...

identify

 

Black Butterflies

 

Black Butterflies & Déjà Vu

 

Black Butterflies & Déjà Vu

 

Black Butterflies & Déjà Vu

Thanks for running this @BlackwingE ! You did an awesome job!

 

My top 10 songs in no order:

Don't Stop Now
Right Girl
Every Road
Like We Did (Windows Down)
Same Suit, Different Tie
Am I Pretty?
Steal My Sunshine
Black Butterflies & Déjà Vu
Do You Remember? (The Other Half of 23)
Winter Means Nothing (Without You)

Honorable mentions:

Inside of You
Color
Love & Drugs
Diet Soda Society
(Un)Lost
The Sound of Reverie

 

We doing top 10s? No order:
The Sound of Reverie
Diet Soda Society
Don’t Come Down
When I’m At Home
Kennedy Curse
Taxi
Raining in Paris
Miles Away
My Hair (their most underrated song)
Don’t Stop Now

 

I guess Black & White really is your favorite record of theirs!

 

Yes, it is. I guess part of the reason is nostalgia. American Candy is a strong second, but there are a couple of songs on there that I just can't stand (My Hair and 24 Floors).

 

My Hair is not a good song

¯\_(ツ)_/¯

sorry @ryanfears

 

I used to dislike 24 Floors as well, that chorus really grew on me though. Reminds me a lot of Coldplay

 

I'm here for Top 10s

In no order:
Some Days
Identify
Right Girl
Same Suit, Different Tie
Am I Pretty?
Everything I Ask For
Girls Do What they Want
Color
Give It to Me
Taxi

 

L
O
L

I’m gonna have to really think about this. I think black butt is there though in the top 10

 

Idk what to pick I’m happy with eithe her but I think probably Black Butterflies deserves to win

 

Is Black Butterflies your vote then?

 

Oh yea haha sorry

 

END OF THE BRACKET /// FINAL SCORES

Identify: 4
Black Butterflies & Déjà Vu: 7

Congrats to Black Butterflies & Déjà Vu for being the band's best song.

Thank you to everyone who participated in this bracket!

 

my top 10 would probably look something like this, in no particular order:

color
rock and roll
when i'm at home
identify
i'm leaving
so criminal
english girls
unlost
sound of reverie
how do you feel