Thrice: To Bracket Everywhere is to Bracket Nowhere Bracket • Page 61

The first match-up should be the final, such a hard choice :/ buuuuuuuut

Hurricane
Salt and Shadow

 

The Long Defeat
Black Honey

 

Hurricane

Salt and Shadow

 

A safe assessment.

The Long Defeat
Salt & Shadow

 

Long Defeat
Black Honey

 

Hurricane

Black Honey

 

Hurricane
Salt and Shadow

 

The Long Defeat
Salt and Shadow

 

Hurricane
Salt and Shadow

 

The Long Defeat
Black Honey

 

Current scores:

The Long Defeat - 7
Hurricane - 7

Salt and Shadow - 8
Black Honey - 6

 

The long defeat
Salt and shadow

 

Hurricane
Salt and shadow

 

Hurricane
Salt and Shadow

 

Hurricane (very difficult decision)
Black Honey

 

Long Defeat
Black Honey

 

Defeat
Honey

 

The Long Defeat
Salt and Shadow

 

Long defeat
Black honey

 

dammit those first two are the clear best songs on the album ugghhhh

Hurricane
Black Honey

 

No one thinks Black Honey is the best on this album?

I get it being overplayed because its a single but I'm able to separate that from the actual merits of the song. It's soooo good.

 

I don’t. It’s a good song but I’d take The Window, Death from Above, The Long Defeat, Hurricane, Stay With Me, and Salt and Shadow over it. These brackets have shown me that my favorite Thrice songs are way different than a lot of other Thrice fans. I think that’s really cool and says a lot about how consistent this band is.

 

It’s fine.

 

The alternating votes between The Long Defeat and Hurricane are making me laugh so hard.

 

Current scores:

The Long Defeat - 12
Hurricane - 11

Salt and Shadow - 12
Black Honey - 11