Silverstein Band • Page 4

huh yea idk thats weird

 

Lost Positives
Ghost
Retrograde
Last Looks

 

Album ranks.

Discovering The Waterfront
This Is How The Wind Shifts
A Shipwreck In The Sand
Dead Reflection
When Broken Is Easily Fixed
I Am Alive In Everything I Touch
Arrivals & Departures
Rescue

 

Aquamarine
Ghost
Retrograde
Last Looks

 

Aquamarine
Ghost
Retrograde
Demons

 

Aquamarine
Wake Up
Secret's Safe
Demons

Love DR and all 4 of these made it an easy choice for me

 

No one choosing Secret's Safe :(

 

If you want to you can, your Secrets Safe with us

 

I did! :) I have all the same as you except I chose Lost Positives over Aquamarine.

 

Surprised ar the amount of people chosing Lost Positives

Worst song on the album imo. Too slow, not very melodically or lyrically satisfying to me. Bummer too, cause on paper I should love it. Poppy atmospheric verses, an epic chorus, and a super strong chuggy lead riff, but I just can't get into it

 

We must stand as one. I mistook Aquamarine for Afterglow at first glance. My vote would've gone the other way if that was the matchup.

 

I think I will, easily one of my favourites on the album.

 

Well, I love Lost Positives and don't think Secret's Safe is all that great haha

 

Hey guys, after you put your vote in here, feel free to head over to the Brand New thread and vote there. the Devil and God is currenlty going!

Sorry for the shameless plug @js977

 

I wish I could vote for all these songs.

 

Struggling to keep up with all the brackets haha, I like how slowly this one is moving!

 

Lost Positives
Ghost
Secret's Safe
Demons

This was my first listen to some of these songs, so I'm going off my first impression.

The Ghost vs. Wake Up matchup was probably the toughest one for me.

I'd consider myself a pretty casual Silverstein fan and really haven't listened to their last three albums much. I'll definitely have to brush up on those.

 

Aquamarine
Ghost
Secret's Safe
Last Looks

 

Aquamarine
Wake Up
Retrograde
Last Looks

 

Scores so far!

Aquamarine: 9
Lost Positives: 4

Wake Up: 6
Ghost: 7

Secret's Safe: 4
Retrograde: 9

Last Looks: 7
Demons: 6

Interesting breakdown after the first stretch of voting; i'm shocked retrograde is doubling secret's safe and i expected lost positives to be a little closer given how excited people were when it was released. i say we give the first round its ~24 hours to see what we get up to, if not longer?
also sorry for the delay in updates, long day today. Feel free to tally up votes if i'm away for a long while.

 

Thanks for putting it all together!

 

Honestly shocked people dislike Lost Positives. I mean, I like Aquamarine but Lost Positives is one of the top 3 on the album.

 

Lost Positives is great but I definitely wouldn't put it top 3 on the album, I think Aquamarine is definitely a better song.

 

There's not a thing I would change on lost positives, especially the verses I think are perfect. Verses on aquamarine are classic Silverstein but the pre-chorus and intro are the highlights for me. Also the guitars sound huge and contrast beautifully with the singing. No wrong answer here.

Also I'd say ghost has one of their best choruses ever.

 

Silverstein & Tonight Alive - Tickets - Baltimore Soundstage - Baltimore, Maryland, February 20, 2018 | Ticketfly