Manchester Orchestra - A Black Mile to the Surface (July 28, 2017) Album • Page 177

My wife said it's the best song on the album, and I'll tell you the same thing I told her.
I love you but you're wrong.

 

I'd be inclined inclined to make it more diverse to show off Andy's versatility. So mine would be something like:

Virgin
Where Have You Been
Colly Strings
Sleeper 1972

METN
Pride
I've Got Friends
I Can Feel a Hot One

Simple Math
Virgin
Simple Math
Mighty

COPE
Top Notch
The Mansion
All That I Really Wanted

HOPE
Top Notch
Girl Harbor
The Ocean

Black Mile
The Maze
The Wolf
The Silence

Others
Anne Louise
I Was A Lid
Opposite Sides

 

I voted The Alien this round. It's one of my least favorites, but is elevated by The Sunshine and The Grocery.

I'll probably vote The Gold next round. I haven't had enough time with the album to decide if I really do like every other song better than The Gold, or if I'm less into it right now because the other songs are more fresh.

 

I'll bite . . .

Virgin
Now That You're Home
Golden Ticket
Colly Strings

METN
Pride
I Can Feel a Hot One
The River

Simple Math
Pensacola
Pale Black Eye
Simple Math

Cope
Every Stone
The Mansion
Cope

Hope
Girl Harbor
The Ocean
See It Again

ABMTTS
The Alien
The Sunshine
The Grocery

Other Songs
After the Scripture
Play It Again, Sam! You Don't Have Any Feathers
I Was a Lid

 

I voted "The Gold", but I think it's more the latter than the former.

 

I came really close to doing this too, haha.

 

I couldn't not. It's my favorite stretch of the album, and I think it showcases what they do on this album really well.

 

Virgin
Where Have You Been?
I Can Barely Breathe
Colly Strings

METN
Shake It Out
Pride
The River

Simple Math
Deer
April Fool
Simple Math

COPE
Top Notch
Every Stone
Cope

HOPE
Choose You
Girl Harbor
The Mansion

Black Mile
The Maze
The Gold
The Silence

Bonus
Escape (Cover)


Mine is very similar to @AngryMan

 

I second this.

 

PIAS... is their best song

 

Where Have You Been? is their best and I Can Feel a Hot One is 2nd

 

Wish I could listen to this on my commute instead of Disney Hits. Though I'm not going to lie, I've still been belting out Let it Go.

 

Finally sitting down and listening to this while reading the photo book.

I thought in the gold he said "we're a daydream". Def like "day drink"

Also. They are 1000% shears.

 

Fine

Ilavlac

1. The end of the world
2. Colly strings
3. Wolves at might

METN
1. Shake it out
2. I can feel a hot one
3. Pride

Simple math
1. Leave it alone
2. Virgin
3. Pensacola

Cope
1. Every stone
2. Trees
3. Top notch

Hope
1. Every stone
2. All that I really wanted
3. Trees

Black mile

1. LeAd
2.. moth
3. Wolf

B sides
After scripture
I was a lid
Girl with broken wing

K

 

oh u guys i get it
the tree on the cover

is her...

...family...
........ tree

 

ILAVLAC
Where Have you Been?
I Can Barely Breathe
Wolves at Night

METN
Everything to Nothing
Shake it Out
I Can Feel A Hot One

SM
Leave it Alone
Pensacola
Virgin

COPE
Every Stone
Trees
See it Again

Black Mile
The Wolf
The Gold
The Silence

 

Just a heads up.. the vinyl is only $9.74 shipped on Amazon right now.

Just got it and am stoked

 

Golden ticket
Where have you been
Colly strings

In my teeth
I can feel a hot one
The river

Deer
Leaky breaks
Pensacola

Girl harbor
Choose you
Trees

Lead sd
The maze
The grocery

 

WHAT! is it the smoke vinyl?

 

not seeing this anywhere. link?

 

Certainly not on amazon.ca lol that's for sure

 

It's the standard vinyl and is available if you look at the "other sellers/used and new" option.

 

scooped that!

 

These may or may not have been posted but I think they are worth adding.

I really hope they do 'The Alien-The Sunshine-The Grocery' on tour, it would probably be even better live.

 

I'm honestly surprised at how much people love Where Have You Been.