I love your username. AMERICA!!!! Aim for the bushes. And your avatar. I prefer The Earth Sings Mi Fa Mi, but I also love BTHATS undyingly.
Such an underrated comedy haha. It's a tough call between the two albums for me, but BTHATS will always have a little edge for me in that it's one of the albums that spurred me to be a music lover, searching out new artists and so on, instead of just a passive listener.
It really is underrated and under appreciated. And wildly quotable. I could easily pick BTHATS for the same reason, it's one of the major albums that sold me on loving albums as a whole and was also one of the cornerstones for my interest in music criticism. However the lyrics of Mi Fa Mi win me over every time. I actually wrote 20-30 pages in college of research over the Mi Fa Mi lyrics, hahah