Rogue One: A Star Wars Story (Gareth Edwards, December 16, 2016) Movie • Page 83

Great movie, and I still give Disney a lot of props just for this/TLJ/Mando alone. Obviously there was a lot of studio interference in this, but what we got was still really cool.

 

Annual “this is the best Star Wars film” post

Also, good interview with Gareth Edwards

https://www.starwars.com/news/gareth-edwards-rogue-one-interview

 

It’s like the 6th best one though.

 

False

 

yeah it's like 5th or 6th for me depending on the day, maybe 4th at best. it's not to say it's a bad movie, i enjoy it a good amount, there are just far far better SW movies.

 

Yeah it's honestly not great aside from the visuals. Just in terms of the Disney era alone, TLJ, TFA, and Solo are better than it. The studio interfered way too much in this one.

 

This is way better than solo

In my opinion

 

idk if i'm going as far as saying Solo is better but, yes TFA and TLJ are ahead of R1 for me.

 

Solo was at least fun, this was a slog

And regardless, R1 can't hold a candle to the greatness of TLJ

 

There are not six Star Wars movies that are better than Rogue One.

 

agreed that this really doesnt get going until the destruction of Jedha, which is nearly an hour into a 2 hr 15 min movie

 

maybe not 6, but there are 5.

 

V, IV, VI, VIII, VII are unquestionably better than Rogue One

Whether you think Solo is better or not (I do), there are at least 5 that are better than this

 

Agree with that for sure

 

The shot of the ship entering the planet at the beginning (filmed in Iceland) alone is better than anything found in the modern films

 

You could take arcs from rebels and clone wars that are 3-4 episodes long to make a movie and a lot of those would be better than a bunch of the movies

 

There are like at least 10-20 sequences in TLJ better than that. The Yoda scene in TLJ is the best Star Wars content since Return of the Jedi. Not to mention Holdo ramming the Star Destroyers, Rey and Ben vs. Snoke's guards, all of the visuals on Krait, it's just so much better.

 

I think the end of season 7 of clone wars is my fav star wars content...maybe ever

 

I think this had potential to be a classic if Disney hadn’t tinkered with it so much.

 

How often we gonna do this

 

No one said that?

 

This is hilarious

 

I think rogue one is the 2nd best Disney Star Wars after TFA.

 

I agree. Haha.