Manchester Orchestra - A Black Mile to the Surface (July 28, 2017) Album • Page 261

I'm joking. But that would be very nice

 

I'd be very happy for you!

 

You’re a year early on the METN, but it’ll most likely just be The Stuffing.

Most everything else I see being way later.

 

I could see this band doing discography shows in the near future.

 

Why yes I’d love this beautiful song on vinyl

 

Can’t wait for the Simple Math anniversary show, because I feel like I’ve only heard maybe half of those songs live.

 

I need to hear Apprehension and Leaky Breaks live.

 

don't they mostly play the same set each tour?

 

What is Sinful Math supposed to be again?

 

It’s a shame they don’t play Where Have You Been as much anymore. It’s one of my favorite live songs by any band.

 

A grunge version of simple math

 

Yea that one and the end of the world are the best songs from LAVLAC live

 

From what I've been told, it's a heavier darker yin/yang to Simple Math.

So, basically my dream record from this band.

 

Wait, aren't you Andy? Can't you just leak it?

 

if they keep Rejoice on it...I'd be sold.

 

Negative on both.

 

Playing Rejoice live and not having it appear on Simple Math or anybfollow up record was odd. Since we are all aware of its existence, I feel like putting the songs or Sinful Math as a whole Out would be awesome. I’m guessing it’s just a collection of non album tracks, but it’s from a period of this band some of us love most.

 

Cope and Hope are the same songs though.

What other Sinful Math songs have been played live? I am under the impression that is what they were calling the other songs that didn’t fit the album. Since Andy writes a lot, they’d natural have a different or heavier vibe.

 

Also, Simple Math was a slight concept album. Nothing overt, but I though Andy said in an interview it was like parts of a conversation with God or something. It’s been a long while since that albums been released so don’t mind me if I’m a little off on that.

 

what is rejoice? if its not a pedro the lion cover then i dont care

 

It’s a 7 minute magnum opus that Manchester wrote played live and never released... still don’t care?

 

The exact quote I’ve seen is sinful math was a grungy, weird version of simple math and it’s where they got the idea of doing hope. You can find that quote with the Hope press release I think.

 

Magnum opus? High praise! Clearly the band don't agree or else they would have released it...?

 

I think it just didn’t fit with the sound of the record. Or maybe it didn’t translate well on tape? Idk but the live version gives me chills

 

They must know the interest is there to hear it.