Thrice: To Bracket Everywhere is to Bracket Nowhere Bracket • Page 35

As the Crow Flies being seeded is hilarious

 

I'm not ready for this

but here goes

Silver Wings
The Arsonist
The Sky is Falling
Burn the Fleet
The Whaler
The Messenger
A Song For Milly Michaelson
Daedalus

gahhhh those last 2 are so hard

 

Come All You Weary
Digital Sea
The Sky is Falling
Burn the Fleet
Moving Mountains
The Messenger
Broken Lungs
Daedalus

 

Come All You Weary
Digital Sea
The Sky is Falling
Burn the Fleet
The Whaler
The Messenger
Broken Lungs
Daedalus

 

Silver Wings
The Arsonist
The Sky is Falling
Burn the Fleet
Moving Mountains
The Lion and the Wolf
Broken Lungs
Daedalus

 

Come All You Weary
The Arsonist - like "Digital Sea" alot, but the "The Arsonist" is "The Arsonist"
The Sky Is Falling
Burn The Fleet - Fire is my favorite disc and Earth is my least favorite, so this will probably happen whenever the two meet.
The Whaler
The Messenger - see above
Broken Lungs - This one was tough
Night Diving - This one was also tough Probably the hardest matchup for me this round.

 

Come All You Weary
The Arsonist
The Sky Is Falling
The Earth Isn't Humming
The Whaler
The Messenger
A Song For Milly Michaelson
Daedalus

 

Come All You Weary
Digital Sea
The Sky is Falling
The Earth Isn't Humming
The Whaler
The Messenger
A Song For Milly Michaelson
Night Diving

 

This will be my favorite part of the bracket

Silver Wings - Something about hearing that opening guitar in Weary live, but I go with Silver Wings because it laid the foundation for Salt and Shadow
Digital Sea - I remember hearing this on a Take Action comp and not getting it until I listened to the entire EP
The Sky Is Falling - This matchup made me realize that Digging My Own Grave is the song I've listened to the least amongst the entirety of Alchemy
The Earth Isn't Humming - The live version is much better, but still what a great cover
The Whaler - Dustin's lyrics here are top notch and I wish this was a live staple
The Messenger - pretty easy matchup here. Not much else to say
Broken Lungs - Riley's drums always attracted me to this song. Great seeing this live last Friday!
Daedalus - my two favorite songs on all of Alchemy so this matchup sucks. Again Daedalus has some of Dustin's best lyrics and vocal performances. I was hoping Seneca would be similar to Night Diving, but they never fleshed that out. Fuck this matchup though!

 

1) Silver Wings

2) The Arsonist

3) The Sky is Falling

4) Burn the Fleet

5) The Whaler

6) The Messenger

7) Broken Lungs

8) Daedalus

 

Come All You Weary
Digital Sea
The Sky is Falling
Burn the Fleet
Moving Mountains
The Messenger
Broken Lungs
Daedalus

 

Hearing Dustin play A Song For Milly Michaelson on his Carry the Fire has forever changed that song for me

 

Silver Wings
Digital Sea
Sky is Falling
The Earth Isn’t Humming
The Whaler
The Messenger
Broken Lungs
Daedalus

 

Come All You Weary
Digital Sea
Digging My Own Grave
Burn the Fleet
The Whaler
The Lion and the Wolf
A Song For Milly Michaelson
Night Diving

Voting against Moving Mountains was not an easy decision.

 

Current scores:

Come All You Weary - 11
Silver Wings - 6

The Arsonist - 7
Digital Sea - 10

The Sky is Falling - 13
Digging My Own Grave - 4

Burn the Fleet - 11
The Earth Isn't Humming - 6

Moving Mountains - 5
The Whaler - 12

The Messenger - 15
The Lion and the Wolf - 2

Broken Lungs - 12
A Song For Milly Michaelson - 5

Daedalus - 13
Night Diving - 4

 

Silver Wings rules, I hate all of you

 

But not as much as Come All you Weary.

 

Come All You Weary is a classic though.

 

Silver Wings would win if it were up to me.

 

https://www.google.com/amp/miklocks...-notes-for-the-alchemy-index-volumes-i-iv/amp For more insight on these songs before ya vote

 

God I love the packaging of this collection so much. One of my most prized processions.

That'd be awful. Granted, I believe the winner will end up being off Air Daedalus

 

The live Thrice version was pretty stellar too

 

Weary
Arsonist
Digging My Own Grave
Burn the Fleet
The Whaler
Messenger
Broken Lungs
Daedalus

 

Come All You Weary (Tough one)
The Arsonist (Coin flip. The main riff/drums put this just over Digital Sea)
Digging My Own Grave (This song has an 1800s saloon vibe to it that I absolutely love)
Burn the Fleet (Probably my favorite song on Fire vs. my least favorite song in their catalogue, easy)
The Whaler (Love Moving Mountains but The Whaler is my favorite Thrice song)
The Messenger
A Song for Milly Michaelson
Night Diving (Another tough one as Daedalus is one of my favorite Thrice songs. The imagery I get when listening to Night Diving is incredibly vivid and that bassline is just sublime. Impressive for a band that doesn't typically do instrumentals.)

 

Hope they do them more often from time to time, since "Night Diving" is proof that they can pull them off.