Brand New - Science Fiction (August 17, 2017) [ARCHIVED] Album • Page 317

YFW is purely nostalgia outside of a few songs that have solid riffs. Jesse's pop punk voice is nowhere near unique or catchy enough to be considered above par the shit that was coming out then and a lot of the vocal melodies are pretty unmemorable. At least TAYF had the call and response going on

 

Brand New are as embarrassed by this as they are of YFW.

 

Used to sing just that part all the time while working retail at a Price Chopper when I was 19, prouder days have been had since then.

 

i feel like this album vindicated my take on that song in every way.

 

This thread has become unleashed

 

This ain't NeoGAF.

 

Haha. Remember when they recorded a new version of "Jude Law" for the radio and thankfully never released a second single from YFW because they didn't wanna become that pop-punk band? Smart, smart, smart.

 

IAAN was easily their worst song since deja

 

no it's not.

 

This feels sarcastic but I don't get it because they didn't release a second YFW single. Is "that" pop-punk band referring to TBS

 

I think it's the worst song the band has ever released. Not kidding.

 

That one song You Will Not Know sucked pretty hard

 

Imagine loving yfw but hating Good Charlotte

 

It was better than all of Daisy, Mene, and Out of Range to me but it reminds me of thew new TBS Sunday "Tidal Wave" and I jam to that so much. Maybe I just love that style of song haha

 

what

 

Nothing I wrote was sarcastic.

 

can you stop quoting me

 

I don't hate them, I just don't listen to them anymore.

There are 1000x better Pop Punk bands out there.

 

We can all at least agree that Science Fiction is a bad pop punk album, right?

 

I guess so, its not very poppy.

 

It's not implausible. I don't love YFW but I like it and I hate Good Charlotte.

 

When I was 10 my friends and I wanted to cover Dance Floor Anthem for our school talent show

Thank god that never happened

 

HITS Daily Double : Rumor Mill - TOP 20: ASTOUNDING SCIENCE FICTION

 

Maybe I'm wrong, and if I am, I am happy to be schooled, but to me it's not so cut and dry as it would be with a book or a movie. Seems like it's more up for interpretation with an album. I've always interpreted the second half of You Won't Know as the climax of the album.

 

im listening to IAAN for the first time in forever. people are really going to bat for this song? i mean its fun and whatever but fuck i havent heard a lazier vin riff on any of their albums, including YFW