Taking Back Sunday Band • Page 66

I think Self-Titled is by far their worst album, but there's still some major jams on there.

 

I'd place it above New Again definitely

 

New Again was my least favorite for a long time. Both of them are by far their two weakest albums, imo. I edge New Again slightly above ST just because of how good Swing, Carpathia, EMG and a few others are.

 

I'll give you EMG. It's a good one

 

This Is All Now
Best Places To Be a Mom

That second one was hard. "Best Places" and "Call Me" might be my favorite 2 on the album, but ultimately "Best Places" has more of what I like from TBS in it, and "Call Me" loses a few points for not being that good of a closer.

 

El Paso
Best Places(Best two songs on the record)

 

New Again and S/T are both the same in the sense that between the 2 records there are a lot of duds, but also some Top Tier TBS songs. Easily their worst two records though

 

This Is
Mom

 

S/T is the album that got me into TBS after previously only hearing TAYF. It's one of my favorites

 

El Paso
Call Me

 

This Is All Now.
Best Places To Mom.

 

This Is All Now
Call Me In The Morning

 

El Paso
Call Me In The Morning

 

This Is All Now- Easy pick for me

Call Me- This is the hard one. Leaning towards Call Me for being arguably their best closer and John screaming "DON'T KNOW WHERE WE'RE GOING" at the end always giving me chills

 

This is tough. One is an easy choice, based on personal preference, but both are good.

The other is tough. Gonna sit on this for a hot minute.

 

Current ToTals:

El Paso-8
This is All Now-12

Call me In The morning-10
Best places to be a mom-10

 

This album is their absolute worst but these are the only 4 gems on it. Was a hard round.

 

El Paso
Call Me in the Morning

 

This Is All Now
Best Places To Be a Mom

Edit: also, to join the discussion from a few posts up, New Again is probably my second favorite TBS record after WYWTB and S/T is def my least favorite. I'm weird.

 

Nah see

perfect songs on s/t: Best Places, This Is All Now, Call Me In The Morning, Sad Savior, You Got Me

Great songs: the rest of them

 

This is all best Place to be a mom

 

Re-listening to New Again right now in preparation for the next round. This album is certainly unfairly maligned. I like it more than the self-titled.

 

This Is All Now
Best Places

 

100% agreed. It was a step down from Louder Now. But I remember it clearly when TBS reunited with Nolan, and the hype was such a let down when we finally got the S/T. I remember so many saying how much better it was than New Again and even Adam saying the same but I never saw it.

 

Yeah I loved New Again.